Serious Eats’ Grilled Cheese Sandwiches Recipe

recipe image

Why It Works

  • This recipe is eternally adaptable, and we provide many imaginable inclusions and adaptations.
  • Our recipe has you toast both facet of the bread, at the side of extra crunch.

A grilled cheese is the first meal that a good deal of us get hold of out learn the technique to cook at dwelling by ourselves. It be the ideal midnight snack or soup-dipper. It be sizable for youth, nonetheless is by no manner grew to was down by an grownup. It be salty, gooey, crisp, buttery, and comforting within the total exact ways.

Serious Eats / Amanda Suarez


You know sooner than you even bite staunch into a grilled cheese whether it may maybe maybe be transcendent or now now not. In a extremely honest one, the cheese slowly oozes from the perimeters. The bread’s face is a honest golden brown that’s suffused with butter. Clutch it up and you may maybe well also the truth is feel the butter within the bread (nonetheless it doesn’t leave your fingers greasy—now now not now now not as much as, now now not too greasy), whereas the crust is crisp yet flexes ever so a little, revealing a layer of relaxed crumb beneath.

And that’s the reason all sooner than you shove that gorgeous cocktail of textures and tubby into your mouth.

So, what are the secrets and tactics to the most productive grilled cheese?

Grilled Cheese, Defined

Forward of we win to the specifics, now we must area up about a parameters related to the definition. Exactly what is and what is now now not the truth is a grilled cheese, anyway? Clearly, cheese and bread needs to be fervent, as smartly as some construct of heat. But does an start-faced Reuben rely? Or how a pair of Mexican pambazo, dipped in sauce and griddled, with a million diverse substances?

Now we comprise thought long and laborious about this, and there are about a widespread suggestions that we judge all people can agree upon.

Serious Eats / Vicky Wasik


A Grilled Cheese Must:

  • Be a closed sandwich, griddled on both sides.
  • Have cheese because the main ingredient. Other substances can complement the cheese, nonetheless none may maybe well even honest crush it.
  • Be made with sliced bread. Thus, a sandwich made with a total, crust-on loaf, admire a panino or a Cubano, doesn’t qualify.
  • Be served sizzling the total diagram by, with the cheese totally melted.
  • Be cooked on a flat, greased surface till golden brown. In crude conditions, it may maybe maybe maybe well even be cooked on an start air grill over an start fire. A grilled cheese may maybe well even honest by no manner be baked or deep-fried.

Agreed? Let’s lock some vital aspects down.

Deciding on the Absolute best Bread

Serious Eats / Vicky Wasik


Excluding for having to be sliced, the most productive diverse rule right here is that your bread can’t be too perforated with air bubbles (or your cheese will drip out) or sliced too thick (lest your cheese now now not soften). White bread and American cheese are what a good deal of us grew up on, nonetheless whereas you should head fancier, the truth is feel free to utilize a good hand-sliced Italian ciabatta, a honest sourdough, or a French boule. Grilled cheese also will be a sizable technique to dissipate day-outdated bread, since the grilling activity will resuscitate it rather.

Picking a Cheese

Serious Eats / Vicky Wasik


A grilled cheese doesn’t work with exact any outdated cheese. You furthermore mght can honest comprise obtained to comprise a cheese with exact the exact melting traits. Dry, crumbly, new cheeses, admire goat cheese, will now not soften smartly. Ditto for overly outdated cheeses, admire a Parmesan or laborious pecorino. A pair of of our favorites consist of the standard American and younger cheddar, Swiss-style cheeses admire Gruyère (or its French cousin Comté), and younger Italian and French cheeses admire Taleggio or Brie. As long because it melts, it’s obtained a convey in our sandwiches.

In the occasion you ruin admire the flavour of a non-melter, it’s acceptable to address it admire every other topping—that is, pair it with a cheese that does soften. A mozzarella and feta combo makes a horny sandwich, as does Fontina with Parmesan, to illustrate.

Grilled Cheese Recommendations and Tricks

Serious Eats / Vicky Wasik


The most productive advance we now comprise viewed for making a finest grilled cheese comes from Adam Kuban. His secret? Griddle the bread on both sides. That is exact. Cook dinner two slices of bread in butter, flip ’em over in convey that the browned sides are facing up, add your cheese, and cessation your sandwich in convey that the cheese is sandwiched between the browned surfaces. (Here’s his widespread recipe.) Not most productive will this win you higher-tasting bread that’s infused with extra butter, it may maybe maybe also give your cheese a head start up on getting extra melty.

Some diverse suggestions to defend in mind:

  • Employ butter, and salt your skillet sooner than at the side of the bread. I love to melt the butter, then sprinkle the skillet or griddle evenly with salt to season the exterior of the sandwich. (You may maybe well skip the extra salt whereas you use salted butter.) In whisper for you to head the truth is wild, circulation over the butter altogether and as an alternate unfold a layer of mayonnaise on every surface of your sandwich sooner than cooking. It will soften and brown, at the side of a splash of tangy-sweet flavor.
  • Low and slack is learn the technique to head. Cook dinner your sandwiches at medium-low heat. Strive to hotfoot up the activity and you may maybe well also quit up with a sandwich that’s sizzling on the exterior, nonetheless aloof cool and unmelted within the heart. It will even be tougher to win it to brown smartly.
  • Relief issues transferring. I love to swirl my sandwiches across the skillet or griddle with a delicate stress your total time they’re cooking, to make certain that they win a wonderfully even, deep-brown shade.
  • Support ’em whereas they’re sizzling!

Fast Upgrades: Straight-From-the-Package Add-Ins

Serious Eats / Vicky Wasik


The easiest grilled cheese reinforce? Squirt a honest amount of yellow mustard onto the plate, and dip as you gallop alongside. The next circulation up is to the truth is—take a seat up for it—attach every other ingredient in between the slices. It be now now not that laborious. Here are exact about a suggestions:

  • Novel greens, fruits, and herbs: To every their comprise, nonetheless we buy new, juicy greens with a particular sweet or tart flavor. Cucumber in a grilled cheese? No thanks. Slices of new tomato, figs, tart apples admire Granny Smiths, pears (even underripe ones!), sweet grapes admire Concords or their tangier Muscat cousins, or even kiwi. Strive sliced sizzling peppers (admire serrano or jalapeño, or, whereas you the truth is would the truth is like to torture your diners, habanero); avocado (unless you, admire me, abominate the total warm-avocado thing); new basil leaves; chopped tarragon; or chopped rosemary. Oh, also cranberries, sliced strawberries, or dried fruits admire dried cranberries, raisins, currants, or prunes (to win extra cherish, soak ’em in sweetened brandy beforehand).
  • Pickles and diverse cured issues: Pickles are the ideal complement to grilled cheese. The acidity and saltiness of a honest predicament cut exact by the filthy rich cheese admire the cornichons on a cherish-pants charcuterie platter. Strive dill or bread-and-butter chips; predicament enjoy; British-style Branston predicament or piccalilli; sliced pickled jalapeños; olives (or, higher yet, muffuletta-style olive salad); chopped French cornichons; capers; or sliced caper berries.
  • Deli meats: They’re easy to add, salty, meaty…normally exact what you desire in a grilled cheese.
  • Jams, chutneys, and diverse condiments: Something else that can work smartly to your cheese plate will work smartly in a grilled cheese. I notably admire sweet, jammy issues admire guava paste, cranberry enjoy, or fig jam. Additionally honest: crimson pepper jelly, olive tapenade, honeycomb (try it out with blue cheese!), ketchup (whereas you the truth is must), grainy mustard, apricot preserves, strawberry or raspberry preserves, orange marmalade, sliced preserved lemons, sriracha (now now not for me, thanks), Buffalo skim sauce, apple cider jam, or a sizzling pepper enjoy.
  • Other issues: Now we start as much as enter wacky territory. Pretzels are sizable with cheese sauce, so why now now not crunched-up pretzels or, higher yet, potato chips? Or, for a meta grilled cheese, how a pair of grilled cheese with crunched-up Cheez-Its? Melted milk chocolate works (try it with Brie), as does Nutella.

April 2013

  • 2 tablespoons (30g) butter, cut into 3 even pieces

  • 2 slices hearty white bread, similar to Pepperidge Farm or Arnold

  • 2 to 4 slices American, cheddar, or Jack cheese

  • Kosher salt

  1. In a 10-creep nonstick skillet, soften 1 share of butter over medium heat till foaming subsides. Add both bread slices and cook, swirling sometimes, till mild golden brown on bottom sides, about 2 minutes.

    Serious Eats / Amanda Suarez


  2. Transfer bread to a work surface, toasted facet up. Set apart cheese slices on prime of 1 sever, then cessation sandwich, with both toasted sides facing inward.

    Serious Eats / Amanda Suarez


  3. Add 1 share of butter to skillet, cut heat to medium-low, and cook till melted. Add sandwich and cook, swirling sometimes and pressing alongside with your hand or a cooking weight, till deep, even golden brown, about 5 minutes. The utilize of a versatile spatula, switch sandwich to work surface. Add closing butter to skillet, cook till melted, then return sandwich to skillet, toasted facet up. Season with salt. Cook dinner, swirling sometimes, till 2nd facet is deep, even golden brown and cheese is totally melted, about 5 minutes; if cheese is now now not the truth is fully melted, screen skillet and continue to cook till cheese is melted. Support straight.

    Serious Eats / Amanda Suarez


Special Equipment

10-creep nonstick skillet

Learn More

About Author

Related Post

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply